Ken–Betwa Tribal Protests: India’s first river-linking project is displacing thousands. Who counts as affected?

By Ramendra Mishra

Ken Betwa Protest

On 24 October, Amit Bhatnagar of the Jai Kisan Sangathan ended a 27-day hunger strike in Panna. Two weeks later, Divya Ahirwar, a young activist arrested while protesting against the Ken–Betwa project and the Runjh and Majhgawan dams, was released from Panna jail on bail after about 40 days in custody. Both stand with tribal families in Madhya Pradesh’s Panna and Chhatarpur districts who have been protesting since April against how they are being moved out for the Ken–Betwa Link Project, India’s first river-interlinking project to reach construction. Madhya Pradesh Leader of Opposition Umang Singhar on October 24 visited the protest in Panna and requested Bhatnagar to end his fast. Bhatnagar ended his 27-day hunger strike by drinking coconut water offered at Singhar’s request. Singhar called for action on a resurvey of affected families, outstanding compensation and dignified rehabilitation. He also visited Divya Ahirwar at Panna jail and called for her release. Ending the fast did not mean that the broader movement or its unresolved demands had ended.

Divya Ahirwar, a young activist involved in protests over displacement, compensation and rehabilitation, was arrested following a confrontation between protesters and police at Banhari village on 28 September 2026. Police alleged that she and other protesters attempted to kill a constable, an allegation that Ahirwar and her lawyers disputed. On 6 November, the Madhya Pradesh High Court granted her bail, with reports on the hearing highlighting questions about the police action. She was released from Panna jail on 7 November after roughly 40 days in custody. Bail does not amount to an acquittal, and the underlying allegations remain a matter for legal proceedings.

A subsequent Dainik Bhaskar investigation, reported on 10 November, drew attention to an important discrepancy in the account of the 28 September incident. While the police FIR alleged a life-threatening attack on a constable, the sub-divisional magistrate (SDM) who was present at the site reportedly said that no such attack had occurred. This is better described as an account contradicting the FIR, rather than proof that the SDM formally changed a sworn statement. Ahirwar also alleged that police forcibly dragged and detained her during the protest. These conflicting accounts warrant an impartial examination of the FIR, witness statements and available evidence. These developments underline the need to separate protest-related legal questions from the substantive rehabilitation claims. Public authorities should publish verifiable resurvey outcomes, resolve contested entitlements, and ensure that families have access to compensation, viable relocation and due process. The core measure of progress remains whether affected households can rebuild secure lives.
The Ken–Betwa River Linking Project promises water security for Bundelkhand, but its legitimacy also depends on what happens to the people required to leave their homes. For tribal and forest-dependent families, displacement can remove the land, livelihoods and social relationships that make survival possible. 

Rehabilitation must therefore be judged by whether families regain secure lives, rather than by compensation expenditure alone. This article examines official project information, reported community concerns and the gap between legal safeguards and their delivery. The evidence raises serious questions about implementation, particularly whether eligibility verification and rehabilitation arrangements address the full range of losses experienced by affected families. Public scrutiny should connect administrative progress with the practical conditions in which people live after relocation.

The project and its promised benefits

Approved in December 2021 at an estimated cost of ₹44,605 crore at 2020–21, the project seeks to transfer water from the Ken basin to the Betwa basin. Its projected benefits include annual irrigation across 10.62 lakh hectares, drinking water for approximately 62 lakh people, and generation of 103 MW of hydropower and 27 MW of solar power. These are planned benefits, rather than proof of outcomes already delivered. 

The Daudhan Dam and link canal are central components. Water scarcity makes the development objective understandable. Yet a regional benefit cannot, by itself, settle the question of whether the burdens imposed on particular villages are fair. The families who lose homes and forests need enforceable rights within the project, including a credible route to rebuilding their livelihoods.

What tribal families stand to lose

The official rehabilitation footprint extends beyond the reservoir. The project authority identifies nine reservoir-affected villages in Chhatarpur, plus thirteen villages affected by land requirements associated with the Panna Tiger Reserve. This distinction matters because families may face displacement through the environmental compensation arrangements as well as through inundation. A household outside the waterline may still lose the place on which its life depends. A land valuation captures only part of that loss. A family may cultivate a small holding while also relying on grazing areas, seasonal forest produce, fuelwood and informal exchanges with neighbours. If relocation makes these resources inaccessible, the household must buy goods previously obtained through its own labour. Cash can then disappear into recurring expenses even where the initial payment appears substantial. This is a risk pathway, not a measured income estimate for every Ken–Betwa household. It explains why a rehabilitation assessment must examine access to productive resources and living costs after relocation. It should ask whether farming can continue, whether livestock have grazing space, and whether new employment is dependable enough to replace what was lost.

Ken Betwa Map
A settlement carries spiritual and historical meaning which cannot be transferred simply by allocating a plot. Sacred places, burial grounds and community spaces should be documented with residents before relocation decisions are finalised. Families should help decide how these places and practices can be protected. Cultural continuity belongs within rehabilitation planning because the relationships between a community and its ancestral landscape are part of what displacement changes. Women face particular risks when their work and entitlements are absorbed into a male household head’s record. Relocation may increase the distance to water, schools or health services, while reducing access to familiar support networks. Women need direct participation in verification and payment decisions, and a practical opportunity to challenge exclusions.

How displacement can undermine household security. Conceptual analysis, not a quantified impact estimate.
Children and older residents also depend on continuity. A new house is inadequate if schooling stops, medicines become difficult to obtain, or daily travel becomes unaffordable. Community members should help assess these risks. Keeping neighbours together, where residents want this, can protect mutual assistance and reduce the isolation that often accompanies resettlement. The ecological and human questions are connected. Replacing diverted forest with another tract does not immediately recreate mature habitat or restore existing community access. Environmental mitigation should therefore be examined alongside rehabilitation, so that protecting one landscape does not make another group’s displacement administratively invisible.

Where policy delivery needs scrutiny

Reported disputes over rehabilitation, gender parity and alleged payments to non-residents make beneficiary verification a central concern. These questions require investigation through original records and affected residents’ accounts. A review should explain who qualifies, how household units are counted and how contested applications are resolved. Fair administration depends on giving each claimant a clear decision and a meaningful opportunity to challenge errors. Eligibility errors can nevertheless have severe consequences. A family omitted from a survey can disappear from the denominator used to calculate payment progress. A high disbursement percentage then says little about that family’s situation. Independent checking must include people who contest exclusion, rather than inspecting only files already accepted for payment.

The government’s August 2026 FAQs say eligible adult sons and daughters, married or unmarried, are treated as separate family units, and identify widows, divorcees and deserted women as separate families. They also recognise eligible landless people whose livelihoods are affected. These official statements provide a practical benchmark against which disputed village lists can be checked The amount and purpose of each entitlement also need clarity. The FAQs distinguish land compensation at the statutory rate or ₹12.50 lakh per hectare, whichever is higher, from a ₹12.50 lakh lump-sum option for eligible families who do not opt for a plot. Confusing a per-hectare land rate with a per-family rehabilitation option obscures whether a claimant has received the correct benefit.

The project authority’s district tables, dated 31 August 2026, record ₹1,140.16 crore in combined land, asset and rehabilitation awards and ₹1,097.14 crore disbursed. Adding the published totals gives approximately 96.23 per cent disbursement and ₹43.02 crore outstanding. These figures show substantial payment, but they do not establish that every eligible person was identified or that livelihoods have recovered. Down To Earth’s July 2026 reporting documents protests over rehabilitation, gender parity and alleged payments to non-residents, alongside accounts of forced relocation and monsoon demolitions. These reported allegations should be tested against notices, consent records, awards and the condition of relocation sites. They indicate contested delivery despite the government’s stated safeguards.

The Forest Rights Act provides an important protection: Section 4(5) bars eviction from occupied forest land until recognition and verification of rights are complete, subject to the Act’s provisions. Authorities should make the status of individual and community claims accessible to claimants, with explanations of decisions and the available appeal process. The 2013 land acquisition framework also contains protections tied specifically to Scheduled Areas, including prior Gram Sabha consent under Section 41(3). Their geographic applicability must be checked village by village; tribal identity alone does not establish that a location is a Scheduled Area. Separately, Section 38 requires rehabilitation and resettlement for irrigation or hydel acquisition to be completed six months before submergence. These are compliance questions requiring records, not assumptions.

What accountable rehabilitation should deliver

The first step should be a joint verification of disputed beneficiary records. District administrations should work with village representatives, women, forest-rights claimants and independent observers. Each disputed application needs an acknowledgement, a reasoned decision and a route to appeal. Eligibility dates should be explained publicly, including how officials handle people who reach adulthood while acquisition and relocation remain prolonged. Disclosure must help residents verify their rights without exposing personal data. Public registers can show names where lawfully necessary, claim status and entitlement categories while masking Aadhaar and bank details. Residents should receive private copies of their own calculations, payment records and decisions. Transparency and privacy can be protected together through careful design.

Second, relocation sites should be inspected before families are required to move. The inspection should check usable housing, reliable drinking water, sanitation, electricity, roads and access to schools and healthcare. Residents must be able to report defects without losing their entitlements. The applicable statutory timeline should be linked to site readiness, rather than treating construction speed as sufficient reason to advance displacement. Third, livelihood restoration needs its own budget and measurable outcomes. Suitable agricultural land, secure resource access and sustained income support should be considered according to the applicable entitlement framework and each family’s circumstances. Training is useful only when accessible work follows it. Officials should track income, food security, debt and access to essential services at regular intervals after relocation.

A proposed sequence for accountable rehabilitation. It complements, and does not replace, statutory requirements.
An independent review should sample accepted claims and contested exclusions, and report separately on land compensation, asset compensation, rehabilitation benefits and actual relocation. Its findings should identify who must correct each defect and by when. Payment percentages should be accompanied by the number of unresolved cases and evidence of service delivery, so that financial progress is not mistaken for social recovery. Finally, regional water planning should keep examining ways to reduce avoidable displacement and environmental damage. Better demand management, local water conservation and improvements to existing irrigation may complement the project. Any proposal should be assessed on its actual capacity, cost and social consequences. Communities facing loss deserve access to the reasoning behind decisions that reject less disruptive options.

Ken–Betwa should be judged against both its promised water benefits and the rights of those carrying its immediate costs. A credible public project must be able to demonstrate that affected people have been heard, legally recognised and enabled to rebuild secure lives. Where evidence shows exclusion or unmet entitlements, correction must be part of implementation itself. Following the ground visit to Panna on 23–24 October 2026, the All India Professionals’ Congress (AIPC), through its Civil Society & Policy Research (CSPR) vertical, initiated “Ken–Betwa Ki Awaaz: Voices of the Displaced”, a public awareness and advocacy initiative centred on the concerns of Adivasi communities and families affected by the Ken–Betwa project. Guided by the principle “Jal, Jangal, Zameen aur Adhikar ki Ladai”, the initiative aims to bring community experiences into wider public discussion through video testimonies, social media awareness, documentation of rehabilitation and compensation concerns, policy research, and dialogues involving affected families, activists, researchers and civil society representatives.

The campaign also seeks to document the concerns surrounding Amit Bhatnagar’s hunger strike and Divya Ahirwar’s arrest, while highlighting the experiences of women, children and vulnerable families facing displacement. Its broader objective is to connect ground realities with informed public discussion, institutional accountability and fair rehabilitation.

“From Ground Reality to Public Awareness, From Public Awareness to Policy Action.” Ken–Betwa Ki Awaaz — Har Visthapit Ki Awaaz.

(Ramendra Mishra is a Business Analyst and public policy researcher with a background in Computer Science and Engineering. He writes on economics, governance, and public policy, with a focus on evidence-based analysis and contemporary socio-economic issues.)

Disclaimer: The views and opinions expressed in articles published on Karmrath are those of the respective authors and do not necessarily reflect the views of Karmrath or its editorial team. The content is provided for informational purposes only. Readers are encouraged to verify information independently and exercise their own judgment before relying on any content. Karmrath is not liable for any loss or damage arising from the use of information published on this website.

Previous Post Next Post